Comparison of direct and indirect determinations of dynamic ventilation rate in a modern dairy free stall barn

Bing Zou, Albert J Heber, Zhengxiang Shi, Songhuai Du, Yaomin Jin, Teng Teeh Tim

Abstract


Reliable estimation of the ventilation rate (VR) in intensive livestock buildings is necessary for studying building environmental control strategies and predicting indoor air quality and air emissions. As direct air exchange measurements are time-consuming and expensive, it is environmentally inefficient to measure livestock building VR continuously in practice. Hence, indirect VR estimation methods have been widely used in modelling environmental control and air emissions, and also to measure airflow in the field. The accuracy of indirect measurement methods needs to be evaluated by comparing with direct measurements. In this study, the direct and indirect methods of determining hourly and daily mean VRs were applied to a mechanically-ventilated dairy free stall barn monitored by the 24-month National Air Emissions Monitoring Study. The direct method was used to continuously monitor fan rotational speeds, and differential static pressures, coupled with periodic in-situ fan performance assessments, to calculate the VR. The indirect method consisted of estimating the VR using CO2 concentration measurements and the CO2 mass balance method. The average daily and hourly means (mean±SD) of directly measured barn ventilation rates for two years were (246±73) m3/s and (245±77) m3/s, respectively. The average daily and hourly means (mean±SD) of barn ventilation rates estimated by the CO2 mass balance method were (287±93.4) m3/s and (287±118) m3/s, respectively. Correlation analyses showed a strong correlation between the indirect CO2 mass balance method and direct measurement methods (r=0.93 for daily means and r=0.85 for hourly means).
Keywords: dynamic ventilation rate, modern dairy, free stall barn, carbon dioxide, mass balance, dairy cow, direct and indirect determination, comparison
DOI: 10.25165/j.ijabe.20201306.5767

Citation: Zou B, Heber A J, Shi Z X, Du S H, Jin Y, Lim T T. Comparison of direct and indirect determinations of dynamic ventilation rate in a modern dairy free stall barn. Int J Agric & Biol Eng, 2020; 13(6): 41–46.

Keywords


dynamic ventilation rate, modern dairy, free stall barn, carbon dioxide, mass balance, dairy cow, direct and indirect determination, comparison

Full Text:

PDF

References


Copeland C. Air quality issues and animal agriculture: A primer. In: CRS Report for Congress, 2010; pp.13–45.

Kundert W R. Ventilation fan control. 1994; United States Patent 5364026.

Keenan J D, Amundsen R N. Assessment of waste heat utilization technologies: Overview. Journal of Environmental Systems, 1990; 19(2): 95–114.

Blanes V, Pedersen S. Ventilation flow in pig houses measured and calculated by carbon dioxide, moisture and heat balance equations. Biosystems Engineering, 2005; 92(4): 483–493.

Xin H, Li H, Gates R S, Overhults D G, Earnest Jr J W. Use of CO2 concentration difference or CO2 balance to assess ventilation rate of broiler houses. Transactions of the ASABE, 2009; 52(4): 1353–1361.

Edouard N, Mosquera J, van Dooren H J, Mendes L B, Ogink N W. Comparison of CO2- and SF6-based tracer gas methods for the estimation of ventilation rates in a naturally ventilated dairy barn. Biosystems Engineering, 2016; 149: 11–23.

Samer M, Ammon C, Loebsin C, Fiedler M, Berg W, Sanftleben P, et al. Moisture balance and tracer gas technique for ventilation rates measurement and greenhouse gases and ammonia emissions quantification in naturally ventilated buildings. Building and Environment, 2012; 50: 10–20.

Li H, Xin H, Liang Y, Gates R S, Wheeler E F, Heber A J. Comparison of direct vs. indirect ventilation rate determinations in layer barns using manure belts. Transactions of the ASAE, 2005; 48(1): 367–372.

Barber F E, Fernandez N, Torres A, Sanz S C. Use of CO2 balances to determine ventilation rates in a fattening rabbit house. Spanish Journal of Agricultural Research, 2011(3): 713–720.

Liu Z, Powers W, Harmon J. Estimating ventilation rates of animal houses through CO2 balance. Transactions of the ASABE, 2016; 59(1): 321–328.

Hoff S J, Bundy D S, Nelson M A, Zelle B C, Jacobson L D, Heber A J, et al. Real-time airflow rate measurements from mechanically ventilated animal buildings. Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association, 2009; 59(6): 683–694.

Chen L, Lim T T, Jin Y, Heber A J, Ni J Q, Cortus E L, et al. Ventilation rate measurements at a mechanically-ventilated pig finishing quad barn. Biosystems Engineering, 2014; 121: 96–104.

Rosa E, Arriaga H, Calvet S, Merino P. Assessing ventilation rate measurements in a mechanically ventilated laying hen facility. Poultry Science, 2019; 98(3): 1211–1221.

Calvet S, Cambra-López M, Blanes-Vidal V, Estellés F, Torres A. Ventilation rates in mechanically-ventilated commercial poultry buildings in Southern Europe: Measurement system development and uncertainty analysis. Biosystems Engineering, 2010; 106(4): 423–432.

Heber A J, Bogan B W, Ni J Q, Lim T T, Ramirez-Dorronsoro J C, Cortus E L, et al. The national air emissions monitoring study: overview of barn sources. In: Livestock Environment VIII, 31 August–4 September 2008, Iguassu Falls: ASABE, 2009. doi: 10.13031/2013.25499.

Lim T T, Ni J Q, Heber A J, Jin Y. Applications and calibrations of the fans and traverse methods for barn airflow rate measurement. In: International Symposium on Air Quality and Manure Management for Agriculture Conference Proceedings, 13-16 September 2010, Dallas: ASABE, 2010. doi: 10.13031/2013.32629.

Pedersen S, Blanes-Vidal V, Jørgensen H, Chwalibog A, Haeussermann A, Heetkamp M, et al. Carbon dioxide production in animal houses: A literature review. Agricultural Engineering International: CIGR Journal, 2008; 10: 1–19.

Brouwer E. Report of sub-committee on constants and factors. In: Proceedings of the 3rd symposium on energy metabolism of farm animals, 1965.

Van Ouverkerk E, Pedersen S. Application of the carbon dioxide mass balance method to evaluate ventilation rates in livestock buildings. Proc. XII CIGR World Congress on Agricultural Engineering, 1994; 1: 516–529.

Derno M, Elsner H G, Paetow E A, Scholze H, Schweigel M. A new facility for continuous respiration measurements in lactating cows. Journal of Dairy Science, 2009; 92(6): 2804–2808.

Aubry A, Yan T. Meta-analysis of calorimeter data to establish relationships between methane and carbon dioxide emissions or oxygen consumption for dairy cattle. Animal Nutrition, 2015; 1(3): 128–134.

Machado F, Tomich T, Ferreira A, Cavalcanti L, Campos M, Paiva C, et al. A facility for respiration measurements in cattle. Journal of Dairy Science, 2016; 99(6): 4899–4906.

Machado F S, Tomich T R, Ferreira A L, Cavalcanti L F, Campos M M, Paiva C A, et al. Technical note: A facility for respiration measurements in cattle. Journal of Dairy Science, 2016; 99(6): 4899–4906.

Pedersen S, Sällvik K J R C B, Danish institute of agricultural sciences: International commission of agricultural engineering, section II. Denmark. CIGR 4th Report of Working Group on Climatization of Animal Houses Heat and Moisture Production at Animal and House Levels, 2002.

Hietanen H, Ojala M. Factors affecting body weight and its association with milk production traits in Finnish Ayrshire and Friesian cows. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section A—Animal Science, 1995; 45(1): 17–25.

Pedersen S, Rom H B. Diurnal variation in heat production from pigs in relation to animal activity. Eurinfo Le Magazine De La Representation De La Ce En Belgique, 1998; 31(1): 10–13.

Pedersen S, Takai H, Johnsen J O, Metz J, Koerkamp P G, Uenk G, et al. A comparison of three balance methods for calculating ventilation rates in livestock buildings. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1998; 70(1): 25–37.

Pedersen S, Sällvik K. Heat and moisture production at animal and house levels. 4th Report of Working Group on Climatization of Animal Houses. CIGR. Horsens, 2002.

Rhodes C J. World meteorological organisation (WMO) report: Global greenhouse gas concentrations highest in 800,000-year record in 2016. Environment Reporter, 2017; 48(43): 1670.

Wathes C, Holden M, Sneath R, White R, Phillips V. Concentrations and emission rates of aerial ammonia, nitrous oxide, methane, carbon dioxide, dust and endotoxin in UK broiler and layer houses. British Poultry Science, 1997; 38(1): 14–28.

Besteiro R, Arango T, Rodríguez M R, Fernández M D, Velo R. Estimation of patterns in weaned piglets' activity using spectral analysis. Biosystems Engineering, 2018; 173: 85–92.

Ngwabie N, Jeppsson K H, Gustafsson G, Nimmermark S. Effects of animal activity and air temperature on methane and ammonia emissions from a naturally ventilated building for dairy cows. Atmospheric Environment, 2011; 45(37): 6760–6768.




Copyright (c) 2020 International Journal of Agricultural and Biological Engineering

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

2023-2026 Copyright IJABE Editing and Publishing Office